Growing Your Own Food: Permaculture, Integrative Organic Farming and Gardening

permaculture-1From: Global Research – by Rady Ananda – August 8, 2011

Review of Meat: A Benign Extravagance by Simon Fairlee (2010, 322 pp.); and Sepp Holzer’s Permaculture: A Practical Guide to Small-Scale Integrative Farming and Gardening by Sepp Holzer (English version 2011, 232 pp.)

While the Bush reign may be described as a war on privacy, Obama’s is clearly a war on food freedom.* As his Monsanto administration arrests organic farmers and distributors, seizing and destroying healthy foods privately contracted and sustainably grown, this tyranny is not unique to the United States.  All over the world, organic, sustainable farmers are under attack by large agribiz actors  who, through government and trade agreements, are regulating them out of business and destroying the environment in the process.

Two farmers arguing against ecocidal hyper-regulation and “conventional” and “orthodox organic” farming are Simon Fairlee of England and Sepp Holzer of Austria. Both have written seminal books that should grace the bookshelves of everyone who gardens, farms or cares about the impact of agriculture on the biosphere.

permaculture-2In Meat: A Benign Extravagance, Simon Fairlee successfully proves that animal husbandry must be part of any sustainable farm, but used under a permaculture system (that which mimics nature) – beyond organic.  “Permaculture” is short for “permanent agriculture” – agricultural ecosystems that are designed to be self-sustaining. It practices natural anarchy.

Ohio farmer Gene Logsdon, who authored Holy Shit and The Contrary Farmer, wrote the forward to Benign Extravagance.  In it, he agrees that food security “is being undermined by well-intentioned people of all persuasions who are demanding rules and regulations in food matters without enough knowledge.”

The use of animals for sustainable farming has long been supported in the alternative ag field. What’s new is Fairlee’s stunning conclusion that animals protect against greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs), turning expert conclusions on their head.

He doesn’t reach this conclusion easily, and he agrees that fewer food animals are needed, but his research exposes the gross exaggerations made by the UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), oft-repeated in the vegan world. Instead, he finds that animals are being scapegoated by fossil-fuel users. To reduce GHGs, he charges logically, reduce fossil fuel use.

Though it focuses on the environmental ethics of raising animals, Benign Extravagance also chronicles the historical move away from a pastoral society to urbanized stockyards and monocultured farms that spread for miles. Today’s industrialized ag system has separated animals from vegetables, with a result of too much animal waste concentrated in one place, and not enough fertilizer in the other. This bifurcation creates toxic ponds at one end and the need for oil-based synthetic fertilizer and pesticides, as well as fossil-fuel using machinery, at the other.

 An interesting tidbit reveals that Wall Street got its name because, at the time, imported pigs roamed free on Manhattan island, requiring a stockade to keep them off the farms. If only it were just as easy to keep the piggish banksters out of food speculation. Other tidbits include how the tsetse fly and the Bubonic Plague guided which animals and crops were raised where.

Fairlee postulates that the interests of agribiz and vegans will converge over lab-cultured meat and spends a little time bewailing transhumanism – a genetically and technically altered human.

Much of the vegan debate for no animals centers on the inefficiency of land use in growing food to feed the stock animals. The oft-quoted and, he shows, erroneous figure is 10:1 – the amount of nutrients in animal meat compared to vegetables.

But when adding in food miles, the need for synthetic fertilizer, pesticides, and fossil-fuel machinery on farms that don’t use animals, and when subtracting the opportunity cost for secondary use of cattle in the trade of hides, value-added dairy products, plus the hard-to-calculate value of warmth and companionship provided by farm animals, the real efficiency figure is 1.2:1, he calculates.

“Food miles may not be over-extravagant in their energy use [accounting for about 10-15% of GHGs], but they are thickly implicated in a centralized distribution system.” It is in a decentralized system that food security is increased and GHGs are reduced.

His calculations and arguments span several chapters. Two refute the absurd and deceptive FAO claim that cow farts account for 18% of GHGs. Fairlee holds his own on this argument, but probably would have appreciated having Olivier De Schutter’s report, Agroecology and the Right to Food, which was published later.  De Schutter is the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food who rejects industrialized farming, instead showing how small, mixed farms provide more food and improve the land.

Among numerous sources, Fairlee also availed himself of information at, a site for “rational grazers,” as well as Joel Salatin’s theories and Michael Pollan’s The Omnivore’s Dilemma.

Part of his equation acknowledges that the world’s subsistence farmers – who are primarily women – all use animals to boost farm productivity (via manure), as draft animals instead of tractors, and to enhance their family’s food security by providing secondary products like eggs and milk, along with other value-added products. And, he points out, herding also saves the world’s landless nomads from starvation.

“While meat is a luxury of the rich, it is a necessity of the poor,” he writes. “Sixty percent of all rural households in poor countries keep livestock.”

Those who want to skip the statistical arguments and exposure of deceptions used to promote industrial farming should not miss Chapter 15: The Great Divide. It is here that an overview of the meat vs. vegan debate is laid out and cemented in common sense. Whether they are aware of it or not, vegans promote factory farms by opposing livestock.

Another paradigm shift he urges involves the concept of the “Tragedy of the Commons” that he refutes with the “Tragedy of Technology,” which is solely to blame for depleted ocean stocks. One fascinating chart reproduced in the book was originally prepared by David Thompson of the FAO, who exposed the gross inefficiency of industrial fishing compared to small fisheries. Below is a slightly updated version:permaculture-3His final chapter details his vision of a permaculture economy where he sees more trees, fewer animals and a re-ruralized society. While much of his book is written with humor, and readers shouldn’t miss his continual references to GOOFs – global opponents of organic farming – it is this last chapter that reveals Fairlee’s genius.

He convincingly argues that famine is not caused by “inefficient animal husbandry displacing efficient” farms. “The conflict” he says, “arises when symbiotic land use is usurped for monoculture designed for export.”

Sepp Holzer couldn’t agree more. He has been described as the “European counterpart” to Australia’s Bill Mollison and Japan’s Masanobu Fukuoka – “as all three independently discovered ways of working with nature that save money and labour and that don’t degrade the environment, but actually improve it.”

permaculture-4In Sepp Holzer’s Permaculture: A Practical Guide to Small-Scale Integrative Farming and Gardening, he provides practical hands-on instruction with a caveat:   Each permaculture system is unique.  The gardener or farmer must understand all the factors that go into completing a self-sustaining ecosystem, including water, wind, sun, soil, wildlife and terrain, as well as climate and nearby pollution sources that impact all of this.

His 110-acre alpine farm in Austria sits between 3,300 and 4,900 feet in altitude (1,000-1,500 meters).  It supports 10,000 fruit and nut trees, 30 different types of potatoes, a variety of grains, mushrooms, vegetables, herbs and wildflowers, as well as domestic and wild cattle, pigs, chickens, introduced snakes and even alpine crocodiles at one time.

“Once planted, I do absolutely nothing,” Holzer told Reuters. “It really is just nature working for itself – no weeding, no pruning, no watering, no fertiliser, no pesticides.”

Having practiced his own brand of permaculture for 50 years, he knows of what he speaks.

Instead, he modified the landscape with terraces, giant stone slabs, and over 70 ponds to direct wind, water, solar energy, and the terrain to permanently support the system.

Not one square meter of Holzer’s ground hosts only one type of plant. Starting from the age of five, he learned that as plant variety increases, parasites are reduced and the ecosystem becomes stable.

As an adult, he realized that most of what he learned in agriculture college and books was destroying the farm he inherited from his parents.  He rebelled.

 His autobiography, The Rebel Farmer, chronicles his battles against ignorant regulators whose rules were destroying his farm.  He has fought regulatory agencies for decades, being mired in litigation and fined several times, and threatened with imprisonment.  One example that cost him in fines involved his refusal to prune his trees as regulated.

He noticed that the only apricot tree faring well during the winter, where temperatures can drop to -29 °F (-34 °C), was the one he had not pruned. The length of the uncut branches allowed them to droop enough to touch the ground, providing support while the snow slid off.  The branches of the pruned trees broke under the weight of the snow, killing the trees.

Sepp Holzer’s Permaculture is filled with photos, diagrams and detailed instructions on every aspect of his mixed-farm system that increased his wealth and the quality of his land. It exemplifies “beyond organic” by mimicking nature in every aspect from natural roads and buildings to natural pesticides (like his homemade bone salve used to protect his trees) to companion plants to vermiculture, and much more.

Instructions aren’t limited to large farms, either. He describes and diagrams balcony gardens and small town gardens that can feed families or whole neighborhoods. And, of course, his theories apply to both farms and gardens.

Nearly everything he does is different from what most of us learn – even how to plant trees. Most of us buy a small tree with a root ball covered in burlap, but his are square with companion plants at the base of the tree. Among several free videos of or about Holzer’s techniques, this one is probably best.

One thing is clear from his book; Holzer would never farm without animals, as they are a part of the play of nature.

“Livestock play a large role in a permaculture system; they do not just provide high-quality produce, they are also industrious and pleasant workers…. The animals actually work for me by loosening the soil and tilling my terraces.” And, they bring the added fertilizer in the form of manure.

Like Joel Salatin on his Polyface Farm, Holzer rationally grazes his animals on various paddocks to ensure no one spot is over- or under-grazed.  He also grows poisonous plants because he’s observed that animals suffering from diarrhea will deliberately eat them. He no longer has to worm his animals.

“The fact that it is actually necessary to become a ‘rebel’ to run a farm in harmony with nature is very sad!”

Many would agree. The joy comes in practicing a holistic approach when growing your own food, he says, giving you independence and healthy foods from an environment that is enriched rather than depleted. It is this very anarchy that will save the environment and feed the world.

Rady Ananda specializes in Natural Resources and administers the sites Food Freedom and COTO Report.

* Here’s a small sampling of articles revealing hyper-regulation:

Georgia cops bust 10-year-old’s lemonade stand
Michigan woman fined for growing veggies on her front lawn
Georgia farmer fined $5K for growing too many veggies
Kentucky Food Club defies illegal Cease and Desist Order from Health Dept
Elderly Man Evicted from His Indiana Land for Living off the Grid
UK family living off the grid evicted from their own land
Australia proposes ban on 1000s of plants including national flower
Urban garden that grosses $2,500 must buy permit for ‘several thousand dollars’

(Meat vs Vegan image)

Rady Ananda is a frequent contributor to Global Research.  Global Research Articles by Rady Ananda

More in this category: « Farm City

Urban Agriculture

66 Things You Can Grow At Home: In Containers, Wit…

From: Planet Green Growing your own food is exciting, not only because you get to see things grow from nothing into ready-to-eat fruits and veggies, but you also don't have to worry about the pesticides they might contain, and you definitely cut down on the miles they—and you—have to travel. As it turns out, with pretty minimal effort, anyone can be a gardener. My boyfriend and I are essentially first-timers this season and so far have the beginnings of strawberries peeking out, tomatoes are on their way, the basil's about...

Read more

Corn Farming Profit Opportunity

From: Agriculture Philippines Corn Price Rises Near Record High Corn prices are surging due to severe drought conditions in the USA and the very low corn harvest there currently. Many food commodity prices are increasing due to a variety of factors affecting supply and demand. The fact is that with the increasing global population food demand and the decreasing global farming harvests is out pacing supply causing prices to go higher, and that creates an opportunity for those already farming and new farmers. The forecast for the next 12 months...

Read more

World Running Out of Farmers

{mp4}jim_rogers_farmer{/mp4} From: Moneynews Agricultural commodities will serve as a lucrative investment in the coming years, says noted commodities bull Jim Rogers. Stocks won't perform well until major industrialized nations pay down their debts and make their economies more competitive, which won't happen overnight.

Read more

Growing Your Own Food: Permaculture, Integrative O…

From: Global Research – by Rady Ananda – August 8, 2011 Review of Meat: A Benign Extravagance by Simon Fairlee (2010, 322 pp.); and Sepp Holzer’s Permaculture: A Practical Guide to Small-Scale Integrative Farming and Gardening by Sepp Holzer (English version 2011, 232 pp.) While the Bush reign may be described as a war on privacy, Obama’s is clearly a war on food freedom.* As his Monsanto administration arrests organic farmers and distributors, seizing and destroying healthy foods privately contracted and sustainably grown, this tyranny is not unique to the United States.  All over the world, organic, sustainable farmers are under attack...

Read more

Supermarkets, restaurants vow to buy local farm pr…

From: Business Mirror – Thursday, 28 July 2011 –  Jennifer A. Ng / Reporter Major supermarkets, hotels and restaurants have committed to patronize, sell and use local agriculture and fishery products following an appeal made by the Philippine government. Agriculture Secretary Proceso J. Alcala also disclosed that the Department of Agriculture (DA) will establish a central depot or distribution hub where small supermarkets could buy their regular stocks of various agri-fishery products, including onions. “The private sector’s commitment will provide the much-needed boost to promote local farm products versus imported ones and subsequently encourage Filipino farmers to produce more and earn more,” said Alcala...

Read more

David Suzuki: Small farms may be better for food s…

From: Straight – By David Suzuki, June 14, 2011 We often assume the only way to feed the world’s rapidly growing human population is with large-scale industrial agriculture. Many would argue that genetically altering food crops is also necessary to produce large enough quantities on smaller areas to feed the world’s people. But recent scientific research is challenging those assumptions. Our global approaches to agriculture are critical. To begin, close to one billion people are malnourished and many more are finding it difficult to feed their families as food prices increase. But is large-scale industrial farming the answer? Large industrial farms are energy intensive...

Read more

Brooklyn Grange

Brooklyn Grange is the product of Wisconsin native and Head Farmer Ben Flanner, who in 2009 started the Eagle Street Rooftop Farm, the first rooftop soil farm in NYC. Flanner’s interest and passion for farm-to-table food led to a farming team with roots in the restaurant business. The owners of Roberta’s in Bushwick, Chris Parachini and Brandon Roy, as well as restaurant veteran Anastasia Plakias, sustainable food advocate Gwen Schantz, and the team’s first apprentice Rob Lateiner, in addition to dozens of volunteers, all contribute to the farm’s growing success. The team partnered with Bromley Caldari, a NYC architect firm...

Read more

Ormoc Leyte Vegetables Farm

From Agriculture Philippines This Ormoc Leyte Vegetable Farm below was applied with Nutriplant Organic Fertilizer to their Broccoli, Tomatoes, Corn, and Lettuce. Their harvest results were very good and they saved on their input costs using Nutriplant Organic Fertilizer, and Apsa80 Adjuvant.

Read more

UA in Naga City

Naga is a mid-size city of 150,000 residents internationally and nationally renowned as among the “best practices” in good local governance in the Philippines and in the developing world. Naga City has maximized the opportunities for governance reform, local capacity building, and improved delivery of basic services created by political decentralization under the Local Government Code. Since 1988, Naga City has been creating and implementing various mechanisms to involve local organized groups, particularly from the marginalized sectors of society, in governing the city. Its City Government has been working closely with highly functional People’s Council and various other Councils, Committees, Special...

Read more

Farm City

Start a farm in the city Change your communityby growing what you eat! Transform your hood for good Urban farming is not a new concept, but it is gaining new support among diverse citizen groups all over the country. Schools, colleges, churches, city councils, government agencies, parks departments, anti-hunger groups, healthcare providers, and nonprofit organizations are coming together to give a fresh new meaning to "greening the city." Residents of Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvaniacreate a garden at an intersection on the edgeof the Wilkes University campus. The projectis co-sponsored by NCAT and SPIN (Small Plot Intensive) Farming. Photo: Lee Rinehart, NCAT

Read more

Organic-farm group wants P200-M government help

from Tuesday, 01 February 2011 20:28 – by Jennifer A. Ng / Reporter NONPROFIT organization Organic Producers and Trade Association (Opta) is asking the government for as much as P200 million in budget support for its programs and projects which are primarily aimed at encouraging more Filipinos to go into organic farming and consume organic products. Opta president Mara Pardo de Tavera noted that her group presented its proposals to Agriculture Secretary Proceso J. Alcala on Tuesday. “We hope to secure the support of the government for our programs and projects. Our initiatives [constitute] an integrated approach to developing and promoting organic farming in...

Read more

How Organic Agriculture Can Feed the World

Witnessing a Shift in the Worldview of Agriculture [By HEATHER GRAY and K. RASHID NURI] Recent research indicates that organic farming can feed the world, and is actually making a significant difference everywhere. In the United States and Europe, universities are reporting that organically produced food will address the problems of hunger and poverty facing the world’s growing population. This is not a surprising finding for organic farmers and advocates of organic agricultural production. The American worldview of agriculture is, in fact, making a radical shift. In 1990 sociologists Curtis Beus and Riley Dunlap wrote a fascinating description of paradigms in agriculture in...

Read more

HARBEST tells Bicol farmers

Philippines, Camarines Sur—Farmers in Bicol were should go for self-sufficiency in vegetables so that the region stops relying on produce from other places that sell at higher prices in local markets. “You should produce your own vegetables because a big chunk of the cost being shouldered by consumers [here] is actually the cost of transportation,” Arsenio Barcelona, president of HARBEST Agribusiness Corp., said here over the weekend before 200 participants in a 10-week training program on the commercial production of high-value vegetables. HARBEST is one of the sponsors of the training course organized by the Department of Agriculture (DA) regional office based...

Read more

Growing Fruits and Veggies in Greenhouses

from: Agriculture Business Week, Posted on August 20th, 2008 Veteran agriculturist Arsenio Barcelona says that adapting the greenhouse technology could really be expensive, but would benefit the farmers in the long run. How would you like to enjoy fruits like melons, tomatoes, etc. all year round? With greenhouse technology, one can enjoy even out-of-season fruits anytime of the year. A greenhouse is a structure built to accommodate and grow plants even in adverse weather or environmental conditions. They were developed primarily to allow agricultural activity proceed despite adverse weather conditions. This is especially true in temperate countries that experience extreme swings in weather...

Read more

Feeding the city

Series Introduction As Tom Philpott explains in his introductory essay to this series, cities for centuries have played an integral part in producing food for their residents. Only recently did cars and trains replace horses — and garden-friendly horse poop — a switch that made possible the long-distance supply chain of big-farms-to-big-supermarkets that’s the foundation of the modern American urban food system. Thanks to a confluence of pressures — rising fuel prices, a nostalgic desire to reconnect with our food sources, a new awareness of the environmental and moral costs of industrial agriculture — that model is losing ground. Not since the...

Read more

Davao entrepreneur pushes farm tourism as a way of…

Source: Agriculture Business Week While the global crisis is reducing consumption across nations and social classes, causing massive unemployment and constricting the world economy to a precarious extent, other sectors are cashing in on some of its unexpected beneficial effects. Among them is the herbs and other plants sector, which is experiencing immense growth, according to Edsa Garden House consultant Pearl Banaag. “Coupled with the thriving niche markets that promote and encourage healthy living for cosmopolitan lifestyles, herbs and other plants are now slowly taking centerstage,” Banaag said.

Read more

An Urban Homestead

Pioneering a journey towards self sufficiency, one step at a time A Family in the CityAn Urban Homestead A Homegrown Revolution Path to Freedom is a grassroots, family operated, original urban homestead located in the midst of Pasadena Surrounded by urban sprawl and just a short distance from a freeway, the Dervaes Family have steadily worked at transforming this ordinary city lot into an organic and sustainable micro-farm. This website documents the many steps the Dervaeses have taken and hopes to inspire fellow travelers on their own life-changing journey. Be inspired to take the first step...

Read more

The history of urban agriculture should inspire it…

By Tom PhilpottGrist — August 3, 2010 Grist food editor Tom Philpott farms and cooks at Maverick Farms, a sustainable-agriculture nonprofit and small farm in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina. This is the first instalment in Grist’s Feeding the City series, which we’ll be running over the course of the next several weeks. Excerpt: “Few things scream ‘Hipster’ like an apartment garden.” Thus spake the New York City music magazine Death + Taxes, and it’s easy to see why. In trendy neighborhoods from Williamsburg, Brooklyn, to San Francisco’s Mission district, urban youth are nurturing vegetables in window sills, fire escapes, and...

Read more

From Seedlings to Servings — 11 Year Old Grows Ton…

From: Good News at Tonic By Contributor: Diane Herbst – July 15, 2010 It all began in third grade, when Katie Stagliano's 40-pound cabbage fed 275 homeless people. Now, Katie's six gardens have produced over 4,000 pounds of vegetables to feed the needy. When Katie Stagliano was in third grade, she planted a cabbage in her family's small garden. When it grew to an astounding 40 pounds, she donated it to a soup kitchen, where it was made into meals for 275 people (with the help of ham and rice). "I thought, 'Wow, with that one cabbage I helped feed that many people?...

Read more

The RUAF Foundation

The RUAF Foundation is an international network of seven regional resource centres and one global resource centre on Urban Agriculture and Food Security. RUAF is providing training, technical support and policy advice to local and national governments, producer organizations, NGO's and other local stakeholders. For more information you are welcome to contact one of the RUAF Partners. The RUAF website contains information on the RUAF-FSTT programme, the activities in each pilot city and all RUAF publications, including the Urban Agriculture Magazine as well as an extensive online bibliographic database and other valuable resources.

Read more